TRAC: Telecommunications Reseach and Action Center
About TRAC | Join TRAC | Order Publications | Parker Event | Advocacy | Newsroom | Consumer Resources | Links | Home

TRACNotes

Vol. 5  # 33 -- August 31, 2007
BECOME A TRAC MEMBER
By joining TRAC, you will be joining thousands of consumers who want to learn and be involved with telecommunication issues that affect all of us. In addition, you will also receive free TRAC publications during your membership.


GET UPDATES FROM TRAC
Enter your information to sign up for alerts and other news from TRAC.






TRAC State-by-State Local Phone Plan Comparison: West Virginia - (Note: This is the forty-eigth in a series of articles comparing local telephone rates in each of the 50 states.) Local telephone customers in the Mountain State served by Verizon, the dominant local phone carrier, will likely pay between $34.50 and $44.49 for basic local phone service with Caller ID and call waiting. Consumers wishing for additional optional calling features tend to pay closer to the high end of that range by opting for Verizon’s “Local Package” plan. Local telephone users looking for only the bare bones would be better served by opting instead for the “Community Caller” plan with the optional services they want added on an “a la carte” basis. West Virginia is a largely rural state, and as such there are many independent phone companies serving consumers in those areas. These companies’ phone plans tend to be cheaper than comparable Verizon plans. For example, Hardy Telecommunications’ “Community Caller” plan costs an estimated $25.80 – $27.80 once Caller ID and call waiting are factored in. This is notably cheaper than Verizon’s “Community Caller” plan. In addition to Verizon and the independent carriers, cable companies like Comcast and Time Warner Cable are offering their digital phone plans in some areas of the state. Comcast’s plans are most comparable to the unlimited local and long distance plans offered by the traditional wireline carriers. However, to get a competitive rate, consumers must also opt for bundled cable television and cable modem Internet service. Without these bundled services, the price for digital telephone service from Comcast is more expensive than comparable wireline phone plans. Consumers with preexisting broadband connections may be able to save even more on home phone service by switching to a third-party carrier like Vonage, though backup power for the service may be more of an issue in mountainous West Virginia than in other parts of the country. Our advice to VoIP customers in other parts of the U.S. holds especially true in West Virginia – keep a cell phone as a backup in case your home VoIP service goes out.

A note on methodology: TRAC’s local phone plan survey takes in to account the prices for monthly service, the federal subscriber line charge, and the two most popular calling options – Caller ID and call waiting. Note that some local phone service plans are only offered as a bundle with long distance service, which skews the total cost comparison somewhat. TRAC’s survey covered plans being offered in a variety of local service areas. Plans surveyed may not be available in every area of the state

TRAC Local Phone Plan Comparison: West Virginia
Carrier Plan Monthly Service Fee Caller ID Call Waiting Federal Subscriber Line Charge Broadband Fee* Total
Armstrong Telephone Company ZoomPhone (includes unlimited long distance service) $49.95 Included Included N/A $49.95
AT&T One Rate Local $40.95 Included $6.50 $47.45
Comcast Unlimited Plan (requires bundling with broadband and cable TV) $39.95 Included N/A N/A $39.95
Comcast Unlimited Plan (without bundled broadband and cable TV) $44.95 Included N/A N/A $44.95
FiberNet Unlimited Local Calling $34.95 Included $6.50 N/A $41.45
FiberNet Basic Local Calling Plan $23.95 $7.00 $2.00 $6.50 N/A $39.45
Frontier Community Calling Plan (does not include Bluefield) $12.00 - $15.00 $6.18 - $7.73 $3.65 $6.50 N/A $28.33 - $32.88
Frontier Community Plus Plan $19.00 - $22.00 $6.18 - $7.74 $3.65 $6.50 N/A $35.33 - $39.88
Hardy Telecommunications Community Calling Residence - One Party Access $13.00 - $15.00 $6.30 $6.50 N/A $28.80 - $27.80
IDT America Choice Service Plan $33.95 - $54.95 $5.95 $4.95 $6.50 N/A $51.35 - $72.35
Packet8 Freedom Unlimited $19.99 Included N/A $39.45 $59.44
Packet8 Freedom Unlimited (without broadband fee) $19.99 Included N/A N/A $19.99
Sprectrotel Home Free Local Plus (Includes unlimited regional calling) $37.95 Included $6.50 N/A $44.45
Spruce Knob Seneca Rocks Telephone Community Caller $15.00 $7.50 $2.75 $6.50 N/A $31.75
StratusWave Telecommunications Community Caller Plus $20.90 $6.95 - $7.95 $4.80 $6.50 N/A $39.15 - $40.15
SuddenLink Basic Phone Plan (requires bundling with broadband and cable TV) $34.99 Included N/A N/A $34.99
SuddenLink Basic Phone Plan (Requires bundling with broadband) $44.99 Included N/A N/A $44.99
SuddenLink Basic Phone Plan (without bundled broadband and cable TV) $44.99 Included N/A N/A $49.99
Time Warner Cable Digital Phone $39.95 Included N/A $39.45 $79.40
Verizon Community Caller $15.25 $7.95 $4.80 $6.50 N/A $34.50
Verizon Local Package $37.99 Included $6.50 N/A $44.49
Vonage Premium Unlimited Plan $24.99 Included N/A $39.45 $64.44
Vonage Residential Basic 500 Minutes Plan $14.99 Included N/A $39.45 $54.44
Vonage Premium Unlimited Plan (without broadband fee) $24.99 Included N/A N/A $24.99
Vonage Residential Basic 500 Minutes Plan (without broadband fee) $14.99 Included N/A N/A $14.99
War Telecommunications Community Caller $17.00 $6.50 - $7.00 $2.50 $6.50 N/A $32.50 - $33.00
West Side Telecommunications Community Caller $1.50 $5.50 - $6.00 $2.50 $6.50 N/A $25.00 - $25.50

* Average of nationwide cable modem prices as defined by Kagan Research - 7/6/06.

AT&T’s “Simplified” Rates are Really Rate Increases - AT&T recently announced a new round of long distance rate increases. First, effective September 1, the monthly recurring charge on the AT&T One Rate Simple Plan will increase by $2 to $7 per month. Second, the effective rates that most people pay on the AT&T Price Protection Plan will be increasing. According to the company, the new rates will be “simplified” by charging a flat 15¢ per minute rate 24 hours per day. However, for many consumers who make most of their long distance calls during the nights or weekends, the rate will likely be going up. This is because prior to the change, AT&T charged a different rate for day, evening, night, and weekend calls, but they also calculated the rate based on the distance called. For night and weekend calling, the rate ranged from 10.2¢-14.45¢ per minute. Evening minutes ranged from 11.9¢-19.55¢ per minute and daytime costs were 20.4¢ to 28.9¢ per minute. In addition, AT&T will begin charging a $1.00 monthly recurring charge on the Price Protection Plan. Since most residential users tend to make their long distance calls in the evening or on nights and weekends, the effective rate that they pay once the flat 15¢ per minute rate and the $1.00 recurring charge take effect will be higher. Apparently, “simplified” means “more expensive” at AT&T. To read more about these changes, click here.


TRAC AND YOU


TRAC Remembers Sylvia Siegel - The consumer movement lost one of its leading lights last week when utility reform advocate Sylvia Siegel passed away at the age of 89. Siegel was the founder of the Utility Reform Network (TURN), a leading California consumer group which has successfully protected the rights of consumers in the state from anti-consumer practices by telephone, electricity, water, and gas companies. Among her many achievements as a tireless representative of California consumers before the California Public Utilities Commission, Siegel exposed overcharges totaling $345 million (more than $1.6 billion in 2007 dollars) by Pacific Gas and Electric, which was forced to refund its customers. Siegel was also instrumental in blocking efforts by Southern California Edison to charge consumers a monthly fee when they did not use any power. Battling all the way to the Supreme Court, Siegel got Pacific Telephone to refund $341 million to customers in 1979. Under Siegel’s leadership, TURN became one of the most influential consumer groups in the U.S. Thanks to California’s large role is helping set national utility policies, it is not a stretch to say that Siegel played a large role in helping protect utility consumers nationwide, not just in California. The consumer movement is forever indebted to the work of Sylvia Siegel and her legacy, one that will not soon be forgotten. To read more about the life and work of Sylvia Siegel, click here or visit www.turn.org.


TRAC IN THE NEWS


Lifestyle a Major Factor in Deciding to Cut the Cord, says TRAC - More and more consumers are considering cutting the cord these days. By some estimates, as many as 1 in 5 consumers are seriously considering cutting the cord with their old wireline phone companies. Before you switch, however, consider whether your lifestyle is a good fit for the wireless-only life. "A young person or an on-the-go businessperson who spends only a few hours of the day at home could be a good candidate since they are unlikely to be using their home phone line anyway," said TRAC Research Associate John Breyault recently in an article on CNNMoney.com. "A stay-at-home mom or a family with school-age children who are at home a lot will probably find that the added costs of extra wireless phone plans outweighs the cost of keeping an 'all-you-can-eat' local home phone line," said Breyault. The trend towards cord-cutting is partly attributable to the amount of investment that carriers are making in their networks, which is increasing customer satisfaction with their carriers and thus making them more likely to switch completely, said TRAC chairman Sam Simon. To read the full CNNMoney.com article, click here.


INTERESTING LINKS


FCC Main Page: http://www.fcc.gov

FCC Complaint Form - http://svartifoss2.fcc.gov/cib/fcc475.cfm

List of State Regulatory Commissions: http://www.naruc.org/displaycommon.cfm?an=15

What do you think? Got a tip you want to share? Nominate your "Scam of the Week" and your "Tip of the Week" - If we select your submission, we'll give you a one-year free membership in TRAC and acknowledge your contribution by name in TRACNotes. Send an e-mail to trac@trac.org to submit your ideas!

TRACNotes is distributed to TRAC members and those who have signed up on the TRAC website "Newscenter." If you do not want to receive TRACNotes, simply click here and let us know. You won't receive these in the future. We hope you choose to remain a part of our network, and that you find TRACNotes helpful. Our goal is to provide you with useful information about what is happening in the telecommunications marketplace for consumers and to keep you up to date on TRAC's policy advocacy. If you like what you see, please consider becoming a member of TRAC by clicking here.

©2007 Telecommunications Research and Action Center. TRAC grants unlimited rights to reproduce TRACNotes or any information contained in it provided attribution is given as follows: "Source: Telecommunications Research and Action Center. http://www.trac.org"